The Challenge: Day Two

“What are we doing tonight?”
“Tonight, we make soap.”

Not really, although I’ve thought that making soap would be an interesting thing to try. No, tonight was a return to a more down-home type of meal: pot roast.

Pot roast is really a classic no-brainer kind of meal. As an added bonus, it can be cooked in a single pot, if you have the right kind of pot. Of course, you need the right kind of roast, too.

Traditionally, pot roast is made with the tougher cuts of meat, because these are the cuts for which the process of browning and then braising is really made. Turning a not so tender cut of beef into something tender enough to cut with a fork is a terrific endeavor.

As I’ve mentioned previously, I picked up some boneless chuck roasts at Costco on the recent foray into the wilds of warehouse shopping. Two per package, about 2.5 pounds each: perfect for a comfort food kind of night. Add in some real whole grain bread, freshly baked, and you could almost imagine it was a cold winter’s day instead of a 90-degree sauna outside.

To begin any good pot roast, if you have the time, browning the meat is essential. If you don’t have the time, and you’re doing this in a crockpot/slow cooker, it will be just as good, but there’s something about that sear…

Where was I? Oh yes: first steps. Browning the meat in a good solid pan. Cast iron works well, or, if you have one on hand, an enameled cast iron dutch oven is even better. Seasoning the meat before browning is definitely in order. Some people like to go nuts with this, but for me, simple is better: salt, pepper, a slight touch of cumin. After being seared in a couple of tablespoons of canola oil, the meat is removed and some onions (Vidalia around here, as they’re in season) and a peeled and cut carrot go into the pot to saute for several minutes until soft but not mushy. After that, deglazing the pan. Since we’re keeping things simple for purposes of The Challenge, I elected to go with beef broth. Normally, I might use a combination of beef broth and a medium bodied red wine. After scraping up the fond (those are the browned thingies on the bottom of the pan after you go through this searing process), the beef went back into the pot, right on top of the onions and carrot. I added more beef broth until the liquid level was about halfway up the side of the meat.

The searing isn’t perfect on the ends, no. But the beauty of this is that is doesn’t have to be. Since most roasts are oddly shaped, getting a good sear on the maximum surface area possible without spending a ton of effort in the process is the goal.

Lid on, and it’s into a 250 degree oven. For hours. The lovely thing about braises is that you get to throw everything together, put it in, and then leave it mostly alone. I turned the meat about every hour, and about half an hour before it was done, tossed in some potatoes and a couple of carrots.

Another half hour or so, and the end result is ready to come out of the oven.

In the midst of all this, I also made some whole grain bread. The problem with most “wheat” bread is that it’s really just white bread with a little wheat flour tossed in. This is not horrible – I am, after all, a huge fan of just about any kind of bread, white included. However, my sister had requested something healthier but suitable for sandwiches. Ask and ye shall receive.

The dough is whole wheat flour, sunflower seeds, walnuts, honey, salt, and a touch of olive oil. And yeast, of course. Halfway through the first rise, it looks a little rough.

After stretching, shaping, and set for the second rise, though, things are looking up.

Into the oven, out of the oven, out of the pan: nothing but cooling rack.

The crust is not rock-hard, and the loaf gives a bit when pressed, just like a regular old sandwich loaf. A taste tester took over after the bread had cooled a bit. And because everything tastes even better with butter…


Gratuitous closeup.

Put it all together, and you get something that looks like this, if you were dining outside.

So what’s our cost breakdown for this hugely satisfying meal?

One 2.5 pound boneless chuck roast – 6.78
Carrots – 0 (leftover from the salad makings last night)
Onions (2) – 1.50 (higher than usual prices at the little produce place nearby)
Potatoes – 2.00
Beef broth – 1.10
Wheat flour – .80
Honey – .20
Olive oil – .25
Sunflower seeds, raw – .50
Walnuts – .50

Total this meal: 13.63
Total per diner (tonight, not including leftovers): 3.41

The leftovers for this will last a couple of days, so the actual price per diner will be significantly less than the first round indicator.

Leftovers, you say? What can you do with pot roast leftovers?

Beyond just eating more of the meat and vegetables with a slice of buttered bread, there’s nothing like a good roast beef sandwich on homemade bread with a little horseradish and perhaps a slice of red onion (or vidalia) and fresh tomato, sprinkled with some freshly ground black pepper. If you were someone unlike me who was currently eating sandwiches, that is.

6 thoughts on “The Challenge: Day Two”

  1. It is way past my bedtime, but I couldn’t resist.

    Those photos and your descriptions of things make me wish you hired yourself out as a personal chef. I know that would defeat the purpose of keeping the expense to a minimum, but it would be well worth it. I’d happily eat leftover roast beef on a sandwich like the one you just built with words.

    Have you given any thought to giving us a taste of upcoming menus, or do you intend to keep us in suspense each day?

  2. That bread! I’ve been lurking for awhile but this loaf of bread brought me out of my shell because I love bread. Love it. Eat it with every meal. If I saw this in my grocery store next to the usual loaves, I’d snap it up in a heartbeat. You should open a bakery or something.

  3. a) i wouldn’t have known you would be so into cooking pre reading mg… and b) i wasn’t hungry before, but now want a huge chunk of bread with stew! (hope progresso’s chicken pot pie soup will do!)

  4. I’ve always loved to cook, since I was a kidlet hanging around at my Granny’s. Unfortunately, I never really had the opportunity to get into it as I owuld have liked, due to lack of money (I ate ramen and tuna for almost ten months one year while in college fulltime and working fulltime) and then lack of time. Now, however, with a better paying job, which still takes up a great deal of time, and more employees, I’m able to indulge myself. It doesn’t hurt to have had a brush with the abyss to help me figure out that life is fleeting after all, even though I always thought I’d live forever. And Progresso is just fine – it’s what’s on hand, I say go right ahead.

    Despite what some people might think, pot roast is in fact quite tasty and it’s as American as baseball, mom, and apple pie. Why do you hate America?

    Thanks for all the kind words about the bread. It’s about time to make some more, which I’m aiming to do on Saturday. Those who are eating it are raving about it, so I’d count this one as a hit.

    Upcoming menus: I tend to think about the menus on the spur of the moment, but I’m leaning toward doing a bit more planning than that to try and keep my day in order. Very important if I decide to get into some other lines.

  5. Your bread looks amazing. Care to share the recipe? I’ve been reading some of your blog( caught you on egullet). I grew up in Florida too, this is bringing back memories.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.